We the people are losing the user interface design war

The car -- the pointer doesn’t point. I have ranted for a long time that because something can be designed, it probably will. Do we need it? Do we want it? Not necessarily. The Wall Street Journal’s Dan Neil describes the new man-machine interface in the Lexus RX 350 F Sport -- the MMI (how cute), a car’s User Interface (UI, or UX/user experience design). His beef is with what sounds like a design-because-it-can-be Remote Touch Controller. He finds it difficult to aim the ‘cursor’ (no back arrow, just a menu selection) to manipulate a menu to back up the selections on an 8-inch LCD display. In a car?? Didn’t AARP say that boomers and beyond have all the spending power?  Good thing, the tested model was $53,000. And isn’t 59 the average age of the Lexus buyer?

The smartphone – the touch is too sensitive.  Only 11 percent of the 65+ have smart phones, according to Pew’s September 2012 research. Probably because the usability of the product is just too annoying for words, typed on an overly small keyboard display on a small glass screen that one squints at and struggles to position a too-large thumb over the back arrow while manipulating the screen with one hand and holding the phone with the other.  And this is the wildly popular Samsung Galaxy S3.  Marvelous device, takes great pictures, does everything that can be imagined – except be usable by people with normal sized hands – and it is slippery until you wrap it in another purchase, the case with the cutouts for buttons and camera. And then it is still too big for one hand.

The tablet – too heavy to hold.  The iPad set the standard for tablet imitators, stunning battery life – and older adults love it. But it is a fairly heavy thing I am betting that they love most when it is flat on their lap or a table. The mini iPad attempts to solve that weighty issue: “What’s the point of having a gorgeous screen and a better antenna if you can’t even hold your tablet with one hand when you are at home on your couch?” And hence the industry at CES and elsewhere of cases, holders and stands for a device that is sort-of portable, ships without a grip – and is slippery.  Older adults like it anyway, despite its limitations – because of its bright screen for viewing (most) content. But it is barely portable. And don’t spill water on it – or drop it.

The TV Remote control – it’s impenetrable. Now that manufacturers have eliminated most controls from televisions, the remote is the only remaining way you can interact with them. Not to pick on any particular model (they are equally awful), I am staring at one now, looking at a sea of little buttons like ‘Link, X, SAP (no, that's not German enterprise software), Viera Tools, SD Card and  Last.’ Last what? What is this, a television remote or a secret handshake to a club we the users who wish to watch TV cannot join without a training course?    

We the people – have lost control of technology.  We need knives to hack away at its retail plastic packaging, a picture in front of us or a training video to use a new touchpad unmarked mouse, or documentation to decipher a TV remote, steady hands for our smart phone, and a carrying case/stand for a too big tablet computer.  Add self-driving cars, Remote Touch Controllers (never mind that the Cadillac’s MMI is called CUE and has ‘capacitive switches' and will soon have the intriguingly named Adaptive Cruise Control). If older adults make up a growing percent of car buyers, is anyone asking them for feedback about the usability, presumed design for all, of these dramatic user interface improvements? Is this what autonomous cars are really about? Manufacturers invent new ways to ignore the driver/user?

Totally hear you on this one

Totally hear you on this one Laurie. It seems as if technology for aging folks is not always different than others, as its a one-size-fits all gadget. I typically recommend the Big Grips iPad holder, originally made for children, to my seniors who purchase an iPad. Heck, I recommend it to many folks of all ages as replacing an iPad is not a good option. Would love to see more companies comprehensive approach to their demographic - proper communication channels, manuals, websites, apps, products, etc

Great Rant!

Love the rant - found a potential solution to the "tablet too heavy" problem in the Eureka Park section at CES - the iSucker (www.isucker.com) - lovely little suction cup holder that also helps with hand cramps and carpal tunnel from holding your tablet too long.

Agreed! I have to assume that

Agreed! I have to assume that these designs are conceived, developed, and refined primarily by 30-something engineers who test them primarily with their own mothers, who smile and say, "Yes dear, it's lovely!"

re: technology

I couldn't agree more ...especially regarding the TV remote. I can only hope the way it's headed that I pass on before my wife....or else I will be destined to watch one channel for the remainder of my days.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.