Nursing (certified) assistants shortage of more than 73,000 nationwide by 2028.
Montgomery County Commission on Aging, September, 2024
What could have happened in the home care industry didn’t. In 2012, based on interviews with the best and the brightest in and around the home care industry, an idea was born and documented. It was radical – the idea of a network for sharing relevant information across organizational boundaries about a home care recipient with stakeholders, family, health providers. In this vision, the care recipient was at the center of this information sharing across the stages and steps of living independently, senior housing, rehab, hospital, and home. Instead of this vision outlined in The Future of Home Care Technology 2012, we have today’s franchised and fragmented home care industry – regionally focused, achieving the most minimal advances in technology deployment.
The role of technology -- big money, big failures. Attempts to Tech-Enable Home Care in 2017 were extremely well-funded, but had virtually no impact on the industry. Not only have the inefficiencies and potential for sub-optimal care remained, but labor shortages have magnified those inefficiencies to today’s near-crisis proportions. Today's home care businesses must compete (and pay competitively) for workers considering easier jobs at Walmart and Target. The Home Care industry, post pandemic, is the recipient of broad family rejection of senior living communities and nursing homes in favor of keeping loved ones at home. In addition, note the growing percentage of childless older adults -- to whom home care services will matter a great deal. Although there is a desire for more innovation among stakeholders, the structure of the industry (franchises) limits transformation. Instead efforts seem focused on improving recruiting and retention -- though ironically, this is still an industry that lacks visible opportunities for workers to grow into new careers. No doubt, a career path could potentially boost retention.
What elements seem even more useful today? Consider these three elements of the 2012 vision for the future and the Table shown below (Figure 1). Now imagine the potential for achieving that Future state in 2022 and beyond, now that the home is increasingly the hub of care for older adults -- comments and feedback welcome:
From (2012) | To (Future) |
Recipient is treated | Recipient is engaged in their own care |
Care recipient (or proxy) integrates own care process | Virtual care is coordinated, integrated on the care recipient’s behalf |
Repeated assessments at each new care location | Data about recipient is transferred and utilized in next stage of care |
Care in the hospital or SNF | Care in the home or setting of choice |
Terminology about care status is in the language of provider | Care status is translated into terms that recipient, AL/IL, family understand |
Care status is disease-centric | Care status is person-centric, includes self-care, physical activity and ADLs |
Incentives favor clinician as primary (and most expensive) care deliverer | With appropriate training and tech support, clinician shares responsibility with home care organizations/staffs |
Transactional, episodic | Decision-supported, outcome-based |
Family initiates inquiries about care | Updated care portals are part of the standard of care |
Home monitoring pilots | Home monitoring as standard of care |
Discharge to rehab or home | Discharge to home care |
Comments
Donovan Kotze
Wow someone I would love to chat too been saying this for 10 years we not preparing for the baby boomers using technology and the entire model is outdated and obsolete. We need a total paradigm shift and we need to future proof this awesome industry.
From Jennifer Smith via LinkedIn
Also grandchildren have become caregivers.. it’s skipped a whole generation in some cases. Grandparents often raised their grandchildren due to absent parents. Grandchildren aren’t equipped fit this responsibility.
From Jeff Weiss via LinkedIn
Great piece by Laurie Orlov on the immediate opportunities to better integrate technology into home care, particularly as of over 80% of adults have no plans to ever move out of their house. Personally I think that targeting Active Agers before they have major health concerns is the way to go (or in addition to targeting care recipients) as they want to detect and prevent health issues before things get serious.